Mostly Resilient

Last Update: 7/31/2026

AI Resilience Score for Religious Ed. Directors:

56.8%

Median Score

Meaningful human contribution

Med

Long-term employer demand

Med

Sustained economic opportunity

High

Our confidence in this score:
Medium-high

Contributing sources

Methodology and Scoring Rationale

To score how resilient religious education directing is to AI, we ask one question in three parts:

First, how much of the job still needs a human, read from five AI-exposure sources: our own AI Resilience Model, Anthropic's Observed Exposure, Microsoft's AI Applicability, Will Robots Take My Job, and OpenAI Signals. We call this dimension Meaningful Human Contribution (MHC) and weight it at 40%.

Next, whether employers will keep hiring for this job over the long term. This dimension, which we call Long-term Employer Demand (LTE), is calculated from BLS data and weighted at 30%.

Last, whether pay and mobility will hold up. We use wage bill and adaptive capacity data from independent researchers (Althoff & Reichardt, 2026; Manning & Aguirre, 2026). We call this dimension Sustained Economic Opportunity (SEO) and weight it at 30%.

For religious education directors, all eight sources had data, though AI exposure was split: Microsoft and OpenAI Signals rated it high while Will Robots Take My Job rated it low and Anthropic landed in the middle. That disagreement holds confidence to medium-high. Strong wage signals lifted the economic score, landing this role at "Mostly Resilient."

AI Resilience Report forDirectors, Religious Activities and Education

$52,100 median salary13,800 annual openingsSOC Code: 21-2021.00

Directors, Religious Activities and Education are somewhat more resilient to AI impacts than most occupations, according to our analysis of 8 sources.

This career is labeled "Mostly Resilient" because the heart of the work, which includes counseling grieving members, mentoring people through spiritual questions, and building real human community, is something AI simply cannot replicate. While AI is taking over time-consuming administrative tasks like scheduling, budgeting, emails, and event planning, those changes actually free up directors to focus more on the deeply personal work that congregations value most.

Learn more about how you can thrive in this position

View analysis
Chat with Coach
Latest news
More career info
Analysis
Chat
News
More

This role is mostly resilient

This career is labeled "Mostly Resilient" because the heart of the work, which includes counseling grieving members, mentoring people through spiritual questions, and building real human community, is something AI simply cannot replicate. While AI is taking over time-consuming administrative tasks like scheduling, budgeting, emails, and event planning, those changes actually free up directors to focus more on the deeply personal work that congregations value most.

Read full analysis

Learn more about how you can thrive in this position

View analysis
Chat with Coach
Latest news
More career info
Analysis
Chat
News
More

Analysis of Current AI Resilience

Religious Ed. Directors

Updated Quarterly

Analysis
Suggested Actions
State of Automation

How is AI changing Religious Ed. Directors jobs?

Right now, AI is mostly augmenting — not replacing — the people who direct religious education and activities. The work is shifting first in administrative and content-prep tasks, exactly the areas O*NET flags as most automatable. According to new Barna research from March 2026 [1], a majority of church leaders personally use AI at least once a month, though only 33% say their church has formally integrated it into ministry or operations.

Surveys cited by Hartford International Seminary [2] show that 45% of church leaders now use AI — an 80% jump from the prior year — mostly for emails, scheduling, bulletins, visitor follow-ups, and sermon research, while fewer than 25% use it for theological content like sermons or devotionals. Practical guides like ChurchTechToday's 2026 roundup [3] describe new "agentic" assistants that can research retreat venues, monitor event registrations, and turn receipt folders into expense reports — directly tackling the budgeting and program-implementation tasks. The deeply human tasks — counseling members through grief, financial stress, or doubt — are not being automated.

As a chaplain writing in the Journal of Lutheran Ethics [4] explains, AI apps can summarize what different traditions say about suffering, but they cannot truly "know" a person or weigh the moral and ethical realities of someone's specific situation.

Reveal More
AI Adoption

How fast is AI adoption growing for Religious Ed. Directors?

Adoption is moving faster than many people expected, but with real brakes. On the "go faster" side, cheap, ready-to-use tools like ChatGPT and AI features already built into Planning Center, Tithe.ly, and Mailchimp make the technology nearly free compared to hiring more staff, which is why Smart Church Management's 2026 guide [5] calls AI "as ordinary in church operations as email." Small and understaffed congregations especially benefit. On the "slow down" side, trust and ethics are huge issues: Barna found [1] that 83% of leaders worry about data privacy, 51% about plagiarism, and 49% about losing authenticity in preaching — yet only 5% of churches have a written AI policy.

Congregants are wary too; the Hartford piece notes a 2025 Pew study [2] finding 73% of Americans believe AI should play no role in advising people about their faith. Scholars in the field are also raising bigger concerns: the Religious Education Association's 2025 annual meeting [6] highlighted how AI is creating new inequalities for resource-limited communities, a phenomenon researchers call "digital colonialism."

The hopeful takeaway for you: AI is taking over the spreadsheets and scheduling, but the heart of this job — counseling, mentoring, and walking with people through their biggest spiritual questions — is exactly what AI cannot do, and what congregations say they value most.

Reveal More
Will AI replace Religious Ed. Directors?

Will AI replace Religious Ed. Directors?

No. We don't think AI will replace Directors, Religious Activities and Education, though we do expect the job to change.

Our 56.8% AI Resilience Score reflects a role where the core work is deeply human, even as AI takes over the edges. Right now, adoption is moving fast on the administrative side: scheduling, visitor follow-ups, bulletin prep, and expense tracking are already being handled by AI tools built into platforms churches already use [5]. About 45% of church leaders now use AI, an 80% jump from the prior year, mostly for emails and sermon research rather than theological content [2].

What stays human is the heart of the job. Counseling someone through grief, doubt, or a financial crisis requires knowing that person, not just knowing what different traditions say about suffering [4]. Congregations seem to agree: 73% of Americans say AI should play no role in advising people about their faith [2]. There are also real brakes on adoption, including concerns about data privacy, authenticity, and equity for under-resourced communities [6].

The economic picture supports staying in this field. Wages and career flexibility score well in our data, and the demand for genuine human presence in spiritual community is not going away.

Reveal More
Career Village Logo

Help us improve this report.

Tell us if this analysis feels accurate or we missed something.

Share your feedback

Your Career Starts Here

Navigate your career with COACH, your free AI Career Coach. Research-backed, designed with career experts.

Explore careers

Plan your next steps

Get resume help

Find jobs

Explore careers

Plan your next steps

Get resume help

Find jobs

Explore careers

Plan your next steps

Get resume help

Find jobs

Career Village Logo

Ask a pro on CareerVillage.org. Free career advice from more than 200,000 professionals.

Latest AI news for Religious Ed. Directors

These articles highlight the importance of embracing AI in religious education, offering valuable insights for students pursuing careers as Directors of Religious Activities and Education. For instance, understanding AI as a tool in theological education can enhance curricular development, while exploring its impact in African churches showcases the need for cultural adaptability. Additionally, examining AI's role in deepening spiritual experiences, such as during Ramadan, can inspire innovative programming. By fostering AI resilience, future leaders can effectively integrate technology into faith-based settings, enriching the educational landscape.

More Career Info

Career: Directors, Religious Activities and Education

They plan and lead religious programs and events, teach people about their faith, and help guide their spiritual growth.

Employment & Wage Data

Median Wage

$52,100

Jobs (2024)

138,900

Growth (2024-34)

+2.1%

Annual Openings

13,800

Education

Bachelor's degree

Experience

Less than 5 years

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employment Projections 2024-2034

Task-Level AI Resilience Scores

AI-generated estimates of task resilience over the next 3 years

1

96% ResilienceCore Task

Analyze member participation or changes in congregational emphasis to determine needs for religious education.

2

95% ResilienceCore Task

Counsel individuals regarding interpersonal, health, financial, or religious problems.

3

95% ResilienceSupplemental

Interpret religious education activities to the public through speaking, leading discussions, or writing articles for local or national publications.

4

94% ResilienceCore Task

Locate and distribute resources, such as periodicals or curricula, to enhance the effectiveness of educational programs.

5

93% ResilienceSupplemental

Plan or conduct conferences dealing with the interpretation of religious ideas or convictions.

6

93% ResilienceSupplemental

Visit congregational members' homes or arrange for pastoral visits to provide information or resources regarding religious education programs.

7

92% ResilienceCore Task

Train and supervise religious education instructional staff.

Tasks are ranked by their AI resilience, with the most resilient tasks shown first. Core tasks are essential functions of this occupation, while supplemental tasks provide additional context.

The AI Resilience Report is a project from CareerVillage.org®, a registered 501(c)(3) nonprofit.

Built with ❤️ by Sandbox Web

The AI Resilience Report is governed by CareerVillage.org’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. This site is not affiliated with Anthropic, Microsoft, or any other data provider and doesn't necessarily represent their viewpoints. This site is being actively updated, and may sometimes contain errors or require improvement in wording or data. To report an error or request a change, please contact air@careervillage.org.